Reviews over the

Thule Shield Pannier

hard and rigid plastic, but well waterproof and easy to put on and take off. My cousin from Switzerland had a similar bag made of woven plastic, therefore more flexible and waterproof

Pros & Cons

Very spacious bags, very easy assembly. You can also detach them very easily, but this does give me some trepidation that they will be stolen quickly. In 2 seconds they are detached and you're off with them. The snap fasteners are tight, but I often find it difficult to click them loose. Especially with gloves, this doesn't work. Currently, they are plenty big enough and, above all, completely waterproof, even with the rain that has already fallen over the past few months. Highly recommended for those who commute to work through all weathers.

Pros & Cons

Test on road and track Really great on the road On the road, however, the panniers tend to move because of the low hook, which has a wide hook.

Nice bags (13-litre set in blue) that fit most carriers. I have them hanging from a Racktime carrier, but for example on a Thule Pack 'n Pedal carrier they also fit. Adjust once and then attaching goes smoothly. Removing them is even quicker by pulling firmly on the "handles". Then the clamps are released. On a bumpy dirt track, the bags stayed on well, so I don't expect them to come off easily. Inside, there are a few compartments for flat items, otherwise it is one big "compartment". This does make the bag relatively spacious (compartments are handy, but also take up space). The roll/click closure works well, although the material of the bag gets a bit stiff in the cold of late (around freezing). This will be a lot smoother in summer, making rolling easier too. But all waterproof plastic bags have this stiffening in the cold. It is a nice set, but for the normal price there is stiff competition from the likes of Ortlieb and Vaude. As I don't know those from personal experience, I can't make a comparison with them.

Pros & Cons

Bags worked well on a bike tour with a lot of luggage.