Reviews over the
Castelli Toe Thingy 2

Castelli Toe Thingy 2
4.0 / 5
Average from 25 reviews
5
4 reviews
4
9 reviews
3
1 review
2
3 reviews
1
0 reviews

2 / 5

Disappointing.

- Saskia, 18 March, 2024

I am a size 40 of my cycling shoe and they are already too small for that.

Pros & Cons

Looks nice
Falls very small
Automatic translation

4 / 5

Don't hesitate if you suffer from cold toes

- Patrik, 10 March, 2024

No surprise, does what it promises!

Pros & Cons

Easy to put on
No more cold toes
Leaves a red glow on white shoes
Automatic translation

5 / 5

Am very happy with the Toe Thingh toe protectors.

- Reinder, 29 January, 2024

The Toe thingy 2 are light on the tip of the shoes to wear. And in spring and winter on cold days.

Pros & Cons

I can keep my feet reasonably warm.
On a 43-kilometre bike ride at minus 4 C,
Automatic translation

5 / 5

Simple effective purchase!

- Tobias, 30 April, 2023

Wonderful solution for dry fresher spring and fall rides

Pros & Cons

Quick to put on & take off
Windstopper keeps toes warm longer
Automatic translation

4 / 5

Warm and easy to store in back pocket of bike test in warmer temperatures later on the bike

- Dave, 16 April, 2023

Keeps feet warm and provides a breathable feel.

Pros & Cons

Keeps feet warm
Automatic translation

4 / 5

Great overshoe for warm feet

- Wilma, 9 April, 2023

Bought these overshoes because it is still a bit too chilly. They do what they promise, warm feet! For me only the forefoot is sufficient. If you want the whole foot warm you should not choose these

Pros & Cons

Easy donning
Price
Automatic translation

4 / 5

Nice for fall or spring

- KAYA, 6 March, 2023

The best option for chill fall or spring days when overshoes are too much. They are tight enough to stick with your shoes, no risk of losing them during the ride. But it's not easy to wear them every time since they are produced in one size. My shoes are 45 and they barely fit.

Pros & Cons

Nice for fall or spring
Tightness
Just one size available

4 / 5

Doing what they need to do

- Henri, 27 October, 2022

I have Shimano shoes and I am having trouble getting them on. They are quite tight, especially at the bottom they don't go around the cleats very well. So I am curious to see how long they will last. Fortunately, they fit and are nice and warm. In the morning cold I cycle to work without cold toes.

Pros & Cons

Easy to wipe clean
Warm
Tight
Automatic translation

4 / 5

Warms well and looks good, but is rather tight cut.

- Gerhard, 13 October, 2021

Good product. Does what it should. For larger (wider) shoes rather too small.

Pros & Cons

Breathable
Good protection against cold
Automatic translation

2 / 5

Don't buy if you have white shoes.

- Rens, 29 April, 2021

Absolutely do not buy if you have white shoes. If you leave them on a little too long after cycling and they are a little damp, the red will soak into your shoes. Had unfortunately overlooked Mantel's mention of this. Do what they are supposed to do though and that is keep your toes warm.

Pros & Cons

Keep your toes warm
Your white shoes will turn red.
Automatic translation

2 / 5

Not satisfied

- Martijn, 13 February, 2021

I don't feel they help against the cold. So bought other overshoes anyway.

Pros & Cons

Still old feet
Automatic translation

4 / 5

Fine, below 5 degrees still a little cold

- Tijmen, 8 January, 2021

Automatic translation

3 / 5

Nice and warm but give off red color

- Lars, 30 December, 2020

The overshoes go easily over your shoes after the first time, the first time the fabric has to stretch a bit around your shoe. It is a good intermediate step from shoes to full high overshoes. What is very annoying is that they are red inside, after a 3 hour ride on wet pavement they were completely soaked, which makes sense. But when I got home there was a pink glow all over my brand new white shoes, both on the shoe and the plastic boa parts. Meanwhile, I have tried everything to get the color off my shoes but nothing has worked yet. It would have been nice if this had been indicated somewhere. With a different color shoe it might not be so noticeable but on white shoes you can see it.

Pros & Cons

Easy to put on
Give off red color on white shoes
Automatic translation

4 / 5

Welcome addition

- Fred, 29 December, 2020

Wear the toes under my thermal shoes makes a significant difference

Pros & Cons

Easy to put on
Toes really stay warmer
Automatic translation

5 / 5

Freedom

- Martin, 29 December, 2020

This model leaves your ankle free and effectively protects the front of the shoe from cold and wet roads. Even on a size 46, it's a no-brainer.

Pros & Cons

Awards
Freedom
Automatic translation

4 / 5

Extra warmth in dry weather

- Lars, 22 December, 2020

If it starts freezing it will not keep the toes warm, but up to 7 degrees and dry! weather they do fine as far as I am concerned :)

Pros & Cons

Easy to use
Extra warmth
Strong
Not as hot as hoped
Automatic translation

5 / 5

Nice and warm

- Petra, 18 October, 2020

I always thought they were weird but they are wonderfully warm.

Pros & Cons

Stays well in place
Think too short if you have big feet
Warm
Fragile bottom, which can be broken easily
Automatic translation